Tricia Taulin (?) I am a licensed Georgia attorney…Â
Â
It is our opinion it is
- Unconstitutional
           Because Fed Govt is sole entity to regulate immigration…
           I submitted Amicus Brief on section included in this bill in New Hampshire where it was found that using trespass ordinance – using state law to regulate presence was unconstitutional
Â
           We are currently litigating Protect Arizona Now – with similar provisions found in this bill
Â
- Federal Law states say you can positively legislate – to provide benefits – you cannot negatively legislate because you are forced to create scheme to determine immigration status – you are asking state employees to determine status… you can’t do it under the Constitution – how are you going to create the scheme.
- You can only verify status through Fed schemes – as they have a comprehensive scheme to classify people regarding immigration. This is solely a Fed domain
- No existing system for denial of state benefits – only federal
Â
Other issues:
Â
You don’t know how much this is gonna cost
Â
Budget and Policy Institute – $200-250 million paid in local and state taxes
Â
Bill is unrealistic as bill doesn’t take into account economic contribution of illegals and doesn’t account for drain on resources to enforce.
Â
BPI – Medicaid expending $44 million in funds on illegals. Compared to $250 million coming in … then illegals don’t take out more than they put in.
Â
It’s inhumane
Â
We are talking about this today because immigration laws are not working. 12 million undocument immigrants and only 10,000 work visas available –
Â
This is not the state’s mandate – but Congress’ to do something about it. We should urge Congress to solve… these piece meal approaches won’t deter
Â
Notes murders and rape of illegals in Tifton….
Â
Kemp: In respect to other people here – speak to the bill….
Â
Some Senators asked question on jailer provision – we think it is unlawful to have jailer enforce immigration law – this is no different from law enforcement doing such.Â